We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (2024)

Every item on this page was chosen by a The Pioneer Woman editor. We may earn commission on some of the items you choose to buy.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (1)

Get great new recipes, plus tips and tricks for making the best one-dish wonders.

By Erin Merhar and Megan Stein

It's no secret that we love casseroles around here. And we do mean love. Whether it's the sweet potato casserole Mom used to make on Thanksgiving or the chicken noodle casserole that's perfect for family dinners, there's nothing a good casserole recipe can't do. After all, casseroles are the ideal comfort food: They save tons of time, they feed a crowd, and... they're just plain good. Take Ree Drummond's famous chicken spaghetti, for instance. It's a weeknight hero if we ever saw one.

So, to honor these crowd-pleasing favorites, we're taking a moment to celebrate all things casserole. Here, you'll discover some fun new facts, pick up some helpful tips, and find tons of great new recipes. We're talking breakfast casseroles, ground beef casseroles, and even some healthy casseroles! You might even find a new dish to add to your holiday menu. Don't worry, we're paying homage to some of Ree's most popular casseroles, too. Dig in to all of it right here, or skip ahead to the recipes and get cooking!

What is a casserole, anyway?

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (3)

Purists could argue all day about what technically constitutes a casserole, but there really is no true definition. If you throw together ingredients in a baking dish and the end result makes everyone feel all warm and fuzzy inside, it's probably a casserole! Some casseroles go by other fun names: stratas, hot dishes, gratins. Call them whatever you want—if your pantry is stocked and you have an oven-safe baking dish, the casserole world is wide open.

So what's inside?

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (4)

Let's talk anatomy: A standard dinner casserole usually includes a protein, a starch, a vegetable, a sauce (or other binding ingredient), and cheese. But making a casserole is not an exact science, and you can definitely break away from this formula. Check out some fun side-dish casseroles and desserts below!

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (5)

Do I need a special dish?

You probably have plenty of options in your kitchen already! But keep an eye out for the size and shape specified in the recipe: This can affect the cooking time and the outcome. If, for example, an egg casserole is in a dish that's too small, you might end up with overdone sides and a raw middle—uh oh!

Here are three things to keep in mind:

If you don't have the size of dish specified in a recipe, use one with about the same volume. For example, a 9-by-13-inch dish and a 3 1/2-quart oval dish will hold roughly the same amount of food. Here’s a handy guide to the dimensions and volume of some commonly used pans:

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (6)

The depth of the casserole dish is important. The sides of the vessel create a little micro-climate in the oven and promote even cooking and browning on top. Tip: Most recipes will list the length and width of the pan only, so buying dishes that are about 2" high are generally a safe bet.

The pan material matters! As a rule of thumb, if a recipe says to use a "baking dish," it most likely means glass or ceramic. "Baking pan" or "tin" usually means metal or aluminum. Metal pans are great for baking, because they conduct heat well.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (7)

Glass or ceramic baking dishes act as insulators—they take longer to heat up but they hold heat for longer. They're best suited for casseroles that don't have a crust, like a crumble or a crisp. These dishes will help keep casseroles warm on the way to the dinner table (or the potluck!) too.

And don't forget cast-iron pans: These retain heat for even longer than glass or ceramic, so use them only when a recipe specifies cast iron. Otherwise the dish could overcook.

PW Test Kitchen-Approved Casserole Dishes

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (8)

The Pioneer Woman 3-Piece Timeless Beauty Cast-Iron Set

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (9)

The Pioneer Woman 2-Piece Ceramic Red Rectangle Baker Set

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (10)

The Pioneer Woman 4-Piece Nonstick Metal Bakeware Bundle

5 Great Casserole Tips

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (12)

  1. Decode your dish size. If you're not sure of the size of a decorative baking dish, flip it over and look in the center of the bottom—you'll likely the quart volume there. Or, use a 4-cup measuring cup and fill the casserole with water. Remember that 4 cups = 1 quart, so you fill it twice and the water almost reaches the top, you are looking at a 2-quart dish.
  2. Keep food from sticking. Give your casserole dish a quick spray with nonstick cooking spray, or rub it down with butter or oil before baking. You won’t affect the flavor of the dish and every serving will come out easily.
  3. Stop those drips! Place your casserole dish on top of a larger sheet pan before baking so you can avoid spilling sauce on the bottom of your oven. You can line the sheet pan with foil too, for an extra-easy cleanup.
  4. Take the temperature. A casserole's cook time depends on the temperature the food is when it goes into the oven. A pot pie, for example, starts on the stove so the filling is meant to go into the oven hot. If you're baking a make-ahead breakfast casserole, like the Everything Bagel Casserole below, the refrigerated dish should come to room temperature before it goes into the oven—don't skip that step!
  5. Cook noodles with care. You should undercook noodles by 2-3 minutes when you're adding them to a casserole. The noodles will keeping cooking in the oven, so this will give them the perfect texture in the finished dish.

Let's get to the recipes!

Breakfast Casseroles

It's the most important meal of the day—and now it's the most delicious, too! Serve up some smiles in the morning with these creative breakfast casserole recipes.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (13)

Pecan Pie French Toast

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (14)

Baked Feta Eggs

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (15)

Biscuits and Gravy Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (16)

Sausage Breakfast Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (17)

Giant Dutch Baby

GET THE RECIPE

Ground Beef Casseroles

For a weeknight dinner that's affordable, quick, and creative, look no further than these ground beef casseroles. There are plenty of twists on your childhood favorites!

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (18)

Beef Enchilada Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (19)

Cowboy Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (20)

Taco Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (21)

Sloppy Joe Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (22)

Tamale Pie

GET THE RECIPE

Chicken Casseroles

Weeknights are hard enough. Make things easier with one of these inventive chicken casserole dinner ideas. They’ll have everyone coming back for seconds.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (23)

Chicken Alfredo Stuffed Shells

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (24)

Chicken Bacon Ranch Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (25)

Chicken Noodle Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (26)

Chicken Stuffing Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (27)

Chicken Spaghetti

GET THE RECIPE

Side Dish Casseroles

Whether you're putting out a big party spread or just need a quick dish to round out a meal, casserole sides are easy (and oftentimes cheesy) crowd-pleasers. Sub in one of these for your usual Thanksgiving fare, or to accompany any main course.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (28)

Broccoli Wild Rice Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (29)

Yellow Squash Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (30)

Brussels Sprouts Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (31)

Sweet Potato Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (32)

Twice Baked Potato Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

Vegetarian Casseroles

These veggie casseroles will make everyone happy—vegetarian or not. They're packed with so much flavor, no one will ever miss the meat.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (33)

Green Chile Enchilada Casserole

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (34)

Baked Gnocchi Alfredo

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (35)

Eggplant Parmesan

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (36)

Spinach Lasagna

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (37)

Vegetarian Pot Pie

GET THE RECIPE

Dessert Casseroles

Boy, oh boy. These suckers are good. You'll want to dig into every one of these tasty casserole desserts. They come together quickly, so you can easily try them all!

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (38)

Wacky Cake

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (39)

Applesauce Cake With Maple Buttercream

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (40)

Apple Cobbler

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (41)

Cookies-and-Cream Rolls

GET THE RECIPE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (42)

Blueberry Crumble

GET THE RECIPE

More Casserole Fun

Can you ever have enough casseroles? Definitely not! Here are Ree's greatest casserole hits plus top casserole dishes to buy, a fun casserole quiz, and even more casserole ideas.

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (43)

Shop Best Casserole Dishes Out There

READ MORE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (44)

Ree's Most Popular Casserole Recipes of All Time

READ MORE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (45)

Can You Ace this Casserole Quiz?

READ MORE

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (46)

Even MORE Casserole Recipes!

READ MORE

Watch Next

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (47)

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

Casseroles

Corn Soufflé Starts with a Box of Muffin MixThis Casserole Is Like Creamed Spinach But BetterHam Casserole Was Made for Easter LeftoversSave Leftover Ham for an Easy, Cheesy Tetrazzini

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

35 Easter Casseroles for a Spring Potluck32 Cheesy, Bubbling Baked Pasta DishesEvery Bunny Will Love Easter Breakfast Casserole25 Breakfast Casseroles That You Can Prep Ahead
40 Easy Recipes Using a Rotisserie Chicken This Breakfast Casserole Is French Toast Made EasyTurkey and Biscuits Casserole with Lemon and DillSave Leftover Ham for Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

We're Celebrating All Things Casserole With an Ode to Everyone's Favorite Family Dinner (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Allyn Kozey

Last Updated:

Views: 6018

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Allyn Kozey

Birthday: 1993-12-21

Address: Suite 454 40343 Larson Union, Port Melia, TX 16164

Phone: +2456904400762

Job: Investor Administrator

Hobby: Sketching, Puzzles, Pet, Mountaineering, Skydiving, Dowsing, Sports

Introduction: My name is Allyn Kozey, I am a outstanding, colorful, adventurous, encouraging, zealous, tender, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.